Call us at 503-231-1444

How to Fix Antique Glass Door Knobs

Posted on May 01, 2015 | 10 Comments

A frequent question we get asked here at Hippo isn't so much a question as a look of panic and frustration.  People come in holding lovely glass door knobs in their hands telling woeful tales of friends stuck in the bathroom or spouses trapped in the garage. They say their knobs are broken and they need a new set. 

Octagonal and fluted (occasionally round or rarely other unusual shapes) glass door knobs are common throughout Portland as well as buildings from the 1920's - 1940's.  And eventually, they fail.  It's a remarkably elegant failure because the solution is fairly simple. Below we'll walk through the most common type of failure and how you can fix it rather than buy new knobs. 

Step 0 (aka the problem) - Your knob spins or falls off in your hand

If your door knob just spins when you try to turn it or even 'skip's when you're turning, chances are your threads have worn out.  Commonly, they either simply wear down completely

or the pressure of the steel will carve out a square shape where there should be a circle:

Before we dive in, there are other common problems that may cause your knob to spin or fall off though, so let's rule out a couple other scenarios first.

Scenario A)  Your set screw is just loose.  Find your set screw in the 'collar' or base of your knob, make sure it's sitting on the face of your spindle (not on a corner). To check, take out your set screw and look through the hole.  If you see a corner, twist the knob a little further.  Otherwise, tighten down the set screw and check to see if your knob still spins.  If not, then you're already done!  Victory lap!


Scenario B) Your door knob's glass has come loose from the collar.  To test this, hold the collar, or base, of the knob, and see if the glass spins independently.  If so, this will require some MacGuyvering with super glue (we recommend the super runny xylene based kind to really get in there and twisting the glass part around while it's wet to get all the crannies) or possibly just replacement.

Assuming neither scenario is true, let's move on to step 1:

Step 1 - Take both knobs off the spindle

This can be accomplished by unscrewing both set screws, unscrewing your knobs from the spindle. 

(Tip: You won't need your set screws anymore, but if you have a whole house of the same knobs, we'd recommend keeping these little guys around because if one gets lost, they can be difficult to replace.)

When you look in your knob's collar, it will probably look torn up, flattened, and mostly square instead of mostly round.  This is another good indicator that your threads have done their duty and are no longer functional. 

Step 2 - Acquire a new spindle

The easiest way to do that at Hippo is to bring in your knobs.  If your threads are damaged enough, you can use a spindle with no threads, and only straight tapped holes.  However, most of the time it's easier to use a spindle with both thread and straight tapped holes.  This way, the knob will screw on so you don't have to battle the remaining thread. 

Most knobs fit on a 20 thread spindle but some do not.  If you come into Hippo, we can trouble shoot with you in person.  If you can't bring it in here, you can take your knob or spindle to a local hardware store and find out the thread. 

We sell offer a 'spindle kit' which includes the spindle, two set screws, and 6 washers. Spindle kits can be purchased here (Note we have some updated information on spindle kits - read more about them here)

f you purchase your spindle elsewhere, make sure you also get two straight tapped screws which will screw directly into the spindle, and many small washers that you will use as needed to keep the knobs from sliding back and forth in your door.

Step 3 - Attach one knob to the end of the spindle

Screw on knob onto the spindle and keep screwing until you get as far down as possible and have the set screw hole over the hole in the spindle.  It's easiest to screw it down as far as possible and then back up the nearest hole.  Screw in the new set screw (through the knob, into the spindle).  Your knob should feel tightly attached to the spindle.

Step 4 - Put the spindle through the door

Assuming your door, latching mechanism, and plates are still attached (if not, attach them now), put one or two washers on the spindle and slide them down to the base of the door knob.  This is an estimate and will likely need to be tested and changed a few times to get it right.  If, even with all six washers, the spindles are still too long for your door we suggest you cut down your spindle instead of continuing to stack washers. 

These washers should nestle between the base of the knob and your door plate. Then push the spindle through your door. 

Step 5 - Attach the second knob

Now, place one or two washers on the end of the spindle poking through the door.  Again, use your best guess as to how many washers you will need based on the length of the spindle and the depth of your door plus plates. 

Install the other door knob, following the same tactic of screwing down as far as possible and then backing up to the nearest spindle hole.  From this point, you can see where your knobs will sit and if your washers are correctly placed.  If you need to add or remove washers, now is a good time to do so.

Once your washers are set, screw down the second knob, screw in the set screw, and voila!  Your beautiful original door knobs once again are working like champs! Victory lap!




10 Responses

Jim Hayes
Jim Hayes

February 22, 2019

I have a 100 year old front door with a latch set on the exterior and a glass knob on the interior. The glass knob requires a split spindle with the small Y on the exterior side which operates the latch and the two flat sides of the spindle in the knob ( interior side ). The knobs threads are stripped and it is held by overtightening the set screw so that is held only by the tension of screw and spindle. I have plenty of spindles but I need a knob. How can I identify a knob that accepts a split spindle?


February 22, 2019

Thank you so much for a great article! My linen closet knob malfunctioned a while back & i didn’t know how to fix it. Good to go now :)

Mary Ann
Mary Ann

February 22, 2019

I have a glass knob going into my den the one on the inside door came off and the screw is stuck and I cannot get it out no matter what I try it will not come out so I guess this means I need to get a whole new knob correct…I think the screw is stripped therefore I can’t get it out thank you


May 04, 2018

I just bought a house built in the 1930s with original hardware. I have two closet doors with this type of door knob. I want to take them off and polish them up. I have done this with other doors in the house and they look great now! The problem is that these closet door knobs won’t come off easily once I remove the set screw and start turning. The one just spins and spins forever without coming off. The other spins a quarter turn and then stops. The only difference with these two doors is they only have a knob on the outside and inside they have a latch that looks like a T. Any suggestions?

Sarah Magallan
Sarah Magallan

February 25, 2018

The outer glass knob is MIA and i cant open the door AT ALL. I have a feeling one of the kids let it fall INSIDE the closet and doesn’t care lol


March 19, 2017

So excited about this article!!!!! Got locked in my room and I’m so relieved to have a game plan come tomorrow! Phew! I never want to have another door knob fall off in my hand..

Meredith Morgan
Meredith Morgan

December 17, 2016

Thank you SO much! I am going to take my knobs to a hardware store straight away and get thread size, then order your kits! I suspected it was spindle-related, but it’s great to know that even a knob with busted threads can be turned into a tapped screw type knob. Many thanks!!


December 12, 2016

Love it when the first website answers my questions, as you have with panache.
Time to macGuyver my glass knob back onto its collar base.
{I won’t try crazy glue}; rather, Guerrilla Glue + possibly a tool to pop the glass back into the metal.

Thanks and cheers! From a 1946 Lake Cabin in NJ,


November 07, 2016

Thanks for this clear and helpful post! We recently purchased a 1930s home in Utah and have falling off knobs. This gave me some ideas on how to fix the problem. Many thanks!


September 26, 2016

I have a glass door knobs that have come apart from the collar of the door knob. We have tried crazy glue and other types of glue but being glass they wont stay together. What else can we use.

Leave a Reply

Comments have to be approved before showing up.

Recent Articles

About Us